top of page

Leadership Coaching 101: Leadership Paradox

Leaders often face paradoxical expectations. Are these expectations always as mutually exclusive as they seem?

Carnival Venetian two faced mask, half black half silver on dark satin textile background
Leadership paradox: When Every Decision Wears a Different Face.

The Leadership Paradox

Leadership, by its very nature, often involves navigating a sea of contradictions.

Imagine a leader, let's say you for example, who stands at the helm of a multinational corporation. On one side, you are urged to push for aggressive innovation, championing cutting-edge technologies that disrupt the market. On the other, you are expected to uphold traditional business values, ensuring stability and continuity. This duality represents just one of the many paradoxes a leader like yourself must manage daily.

Further complicating his role, you must also embody the traits of a humble hero. Being celebrated for your visionary achievements, yet must remain grounded and relatable to inspire the team. Each day presents a balancing act of maintaining authority while being approachable, driving hard bargains while nurturing partnerships, and safeguarding the company’s secrets while promoting transparency.

These paradoxical expectations are not unique to just yourself, but are emblematic of leadership roles across spectrums. From business executives to political leaders to life coaches & entrepreneurs, the demand to navigate these complex dualities is both a challenge and a necessity.

Join us on CLCI Live as Jen Long (ACC), Jerome LeDuff (MCPC), Lisa Finck (MCC) Anthony Lopez (MCPC), and Brooke Adair Walters (ACC) find out how to resolve these paradoxes so you can navigate your role as a leader with confidence and authority.

Contradicting Expectations

People often place paradoxical expectations on their leaders, but it’s not uncommon for leaders themselves to adopt these conflicting demands as personal benchmarks

Take the example of being liked versus being respected. It's commonly debated whether leaders should prioritize being liked or respected. The expectation to achieve both can create a paradox, especially in leadership roles where respect might often come at the cost of popularity or efficacy. Interview prep advice frequently underscores this, suggesting that candidates for leadership positions should lean towards being respected rather than liked.

Another paradox involves transparency versus confidentiality. Leaders are expected to be open and communicative yet also required to maintain confidentiality and security. This balancing act raises questions about trust and transparency. How can a leader be seen as honest and open if they must also withhold information for strategic purposes?

Leadership also demands a balance between autonomy and control. Leaders must empower their team to make decisions and foster independence but simultaneously maintain control and provide clear direction. This paradox challenges leaders to fine-tune their management styles to both inspire initiative and ensure alignment with organizational goals.

Lastly, the conflict between focusing on the present versus planning for the future is a classic leadership paradox. This is particularly relevant in life coaching, where clients may struggle with prioritizing daily tasks over long-term goals or vice versa. As a coach, emphasizing the importance of managing this balance is crucial. Helping leaders navigate these paradoxes not only enhances their effectiveness but also supports their personal growth and adaptability.

Aiming For Balance

Leadership is often about navigating between seemingly contradictory duties. But are the paradoxical expectations of leaders truly mutually exclusive? Must we choose between one or the other?

NO! We can find balance! We can master the paradoxes!

Leaders can, and should, strive to master these paradoxes to create transformative outcomes. Consider the common leadership challenge of balancing freedom and control within a team. True leadership involves giving team members the autonomy to make decisions while still guiding them as a manager. This doesn't mean micromanaging every detail but rather stepping back and allowing the team to navigate their own paths, even if it means making mistakes.

Mistakes are not just inevitable; they are invaluable learning opportunities. In this sense, a leader's ability to allow space for errors mirrors the approach of a life coach. Both roles involve fostering an environment where individuals feel safe to experiment, fail, and grow. This approach not only helps solve problems independently but also encourages a mindset that comfortably holds two opposing ideas simultaneously.

For instance, a life coach leading a coaching session—or managing their coaching business—must balance providing insights with empowering clients to discover their own solutions. A coach needs to trust in the process and in the client's ability to grow from the experience, much like a leader trusts their team's capacity for self-directed problem-solving.

Leadership and coaching, viewed as a system, means understanding how different seemingly contradictory elements influence one another and need simultaneous balance. This perspective is crucial, as the coach-as-leader who can inhabit both elements of a paradox effectively distinguish themselves from the insecure coach, who merely avoids the paradox. The coach-as-leader see the interconnectedness of actions and outcomes and manage these dynamics to foster an environment of growth and innovation for the client or team.

Successful leadership—and life coaching—relies on embracing and managing paradoxes. It requires a profound trust in the potential of paradoxes and a commitment to fostering an environment where that potential can be realized.


Thank you,

Jen Long (ACC), Jerome LeDuff (MCPC), Lisa Finck (MCC) Anthony Lopez (MCPC), and Brooke Adair Walters (ACC)!

We now stream from our site! Watch by clicking here!

We also now stream live on YouTube! Subscribe to our channel and don't miss out!

Don't miss out on our 3-day life coach classes, it's an education that is beneficial for life, not just for life coaches!


bottom of page